Esempio n. 1
0
def mk_variant_assign_clauses(lhs, rhs):
    n = lhs.rep
    new_n = new(n)
    args = lhs.args
    dlhs = new_n(*sym_placeholders(n))
    vs = dlhs.args
    eqs = [
        eq_atom(v, a) for (v, a) in zip(vs, args)
        if not isinstance(a, Variable)
    ]
    rn = dict((a.rep, v) for v, a in zip(vs, args) if isinstance(a, Variable))
    drhs = substitute_ast(rhs, rn)
    nondet = n.suffix("_nd").skolem()
    if eqs:
        nondet = Ite(And(*eqs), nondet, n(*dlhs.args))
    lsort, rsort = lhs.sort, rhs.sort
    fmlas = [
        Iff(
            pto(lsort, rsort)(dlhs, Variable('X', rsort)),
            Equals(Variable('X', rsort), drhs))
    ]
    for s in ivy_module.module.variants[lsort.name]:
        if s != rsort:
            fmlas.append(Not(pto(lsort, s)(dlhs, Variable('X', s))))
    new_clauses = Clauses(fmlas, [Definition(dlhs, nondet)])
    return new_clauses
Esempio n. 2
0
    def handle(self,action,env):

        def my_is_skolem(x):
            return tr.is_skolem(x) and x not in self.cnsts

        def show_sym(v,decd,val):
            if all(x in inv_env or not my_is_skolem(x) and
                   not tr.is_new(x) and x not in env for x in ilu.used_symbols_ast(decd)):
                expr = ilu.rename_ast(decd,inv_env)
                if not (expr in self.current and self.current[expr] == val):
                    print '        {} = {}'.format(expr,val)
                    self.current[expr] = val

        if hasattr(action,'lineno'):
#            print '        env: {}'.format('{'+','.join('{}:{}'.format(x,y) for x,y in env.iteritems())+'}')
            inv_env = dict((y,x) for x,y in env.iteritems())
            for v in self.aiger.inputs:
                if v in self.decoder:
                    show_sym(v,self.decoder[v],self.aiger.get_sym(v))
            rn = dict((x,tr.new(x)) for x in self.stvarset)
            for v in self.aiger.latches:
                if v in self.decoder:
                    decd = self.decoder[v]
                    show_sym(v,ilu.rename_ast(decd,rn),self.aiger.get_next_sym(v))

            print '    {}{}'.format(action.lineno,action)
Esempio n. 3
0
    def action_update(self, domain, pvars):
        lhs, rhs = self.args
        n = lhs.rep

        # Handle the hierarchical case
        if n in domain.hierarchy:
            asgns = [
                postfix_atoms_ast(self, Atom(x, []))
                for x in domain.hierarchy[n]
            ]
            res = unzip_append(
                [asgn.action_update(domain, pvars) for asgn in asgns])
            return res

        # If the lhs application is partial, make it total by adding parameters
        xtra = len(lhs.rep.sort.dom) - len(lhs.args)
        if xtra < 0:
            raise IvyError(self,
                           "too many parameters in assignment to " + lhs.rep)
        if xtra > 0:
            extend = sym_placeholders(lhs.rep)[-xtra:]
            extend = variables_distinct_list_ast(extend,
                                                 self)  # get unused variables
            lhs = add_parameters_ast(lhs, extend)
            # Assignment of individual to a boolean is a special case
            if is_individual_ast(rhs) and not is_individual_ast(lhs):
                rhs = eq_atom(extend[-1],
                              add_parameters_ast(rhs, extend[0:-1]))
            else:
                rhs = add_parameters_ast(rhs, extend)

        type_check(domain, rhs)
        if is_individual_ast(lhs) != is_individual_ast(rhs):
            #            print type(lhs.rep)
            #            print str(lhs.rep)
            #            print type(lhs.rep.sort)
            #            print "lhs: %s: %s" % (lhs,type(lhs))
            #            print "rhs: %s: %s" % (rhs,type(rhs))
            raise IvyError(self,
                           "sort mismatch in assignment to {}".format(lhs.rep))

        new_n = new(n)
        args = lhs.args
        dlhs = new_n(*sym_placeholders(n))
        vs = dlhs.args
        eqs = [
            eq_atom(v, a) for (v, a) in zip(vs, args)
            if not isinstance(a, Variable)
        ]
        rn = dict(
            (a.rep, v) for v, a in zip(vs, args) if isinstance(a, Variable))
        drhs = substitute_ast(rhs, rn)
        if eqs:
            drhs = Ite(And(*eqs), drhs, n(*dlhs.args))
        new_clauses = Clauses([], [Definition(dlhs, drhs)])
        #        print "assign new_clauses = {}".format(new_clauses)
        return ([n], new_clauses, false_clauses())
Esempio n. 4
0
 def action_update(self,domain,pvars):
     lit = self.args[0]
     n = lit.atom.relname
     new_n = new(n)
     args = lit.atom.args
     vs = sym_placeholders(n)
     eqs = [Atom(equals,[v,a]) for (v,a) in zip(vs,args) if not isinstance(a,Variable)]
     new_clauses = And(*([Or(sign(lit.polarity,Atom(new_n,vs)),sign(1-lit.polarity,Atom(n,vs))),
                          sign(lit.polarity,Atom(new_n,args))] +
                         [Or(*([sign(0,Atom(new_n,vs)),sign(1,Atom(n,vs))] + [eq])) for eq in eqs] +
                         [Or(*([sign(1,Atom(new_n,vs)),sign(0,Atom(n,vs))] + [eq])) for eq in eqs]))
     new_clauses = formula_to_clauses(new_clauses)
     return ([n], new_clauses, false_clauses())
Esempio n. 5
0
def mk_assign_clauses(lhs,rhs):
    n = lhs.rep
    new_n = new(n)
    args = lhs.args
    dlhs = new_n(*sym_placeholders(n))
    vs = dlhs.args
    eqs = [eq_atom(v,a) for (v,a) in zip(vs,args) if not isinstance(a,Variable)]
    rn = dict((a.rep,v) for v,a in zip(vs,args) if isinstance(a,Variable))
    drhs = substitute_ast(rhs,rn)
    if eqs:
        drhs = Ite(And(*eqs),drhs,n(*dlhs.args))
    new_clauses = Clauses([],[Definition(dlhs,drhs)])
    return new_clauses
Esempio n. 6
0
 def action_update(self,domain,pvars):
     lit = self.args[0]
     n = lit.atom.relname
     new_n = new(n)
     args = lit.atom.args
     vs = sym_placeholders(n)
     eqs = [Atom(equals,[v,a]) for (v,a) in zip(vs,args) if not isinstance(a,Variable)]
     new_clauses = And(*([Or(sign(lit.polarity,Atom(new_n,vs)),sign(1-lit.polarity,Atom(n,vs))),
                          sign(lit.polarity,Atom(new_n,args))] +
                         [Or(*([sign(0,Atom(new_n,vs)),sign(1,Atom(n,vs))] + [eq])) for eq in eqs] +
                         [Or(*([sign(1,Atom(new_n,vs)),sign(0,Atom(n,vs))] + [eq])) for eq in eqs]))
     new_clauses = formula_to_clauses(new_clauses)
     return ([n], new_clauses, false_clauses())
Esempio n. 7
0
 def action_update(self,domain,pvars):
     lhs = self.args[0]
     n = lhs.rep
     new_n = new(n)
     args = lhs.args
     vs = [Variable("X%d" % i,s) for i,s in enumerate(n.sort.dom)]
     eqs = [eq_atom(v,a) for (v,a) in zip(vs,args) if not isinstance(a,Variable)]
     if is_atom(lhs):
         clauses = And(*([Or(Not(Atom(new_n,vs)),Atom(n,vs),eq) for eq in eqs] +
                         [Or(Atom(new_n,vs),Not(Atom(n,vs)),eq) for eq in eqs]))
     elif is_individual_ast(lhs.rep):
         clauses = And(*[Or(eq_atom(type(lhs)(new_n,vs),type(lhs)(n,vs)),eq) for eq in eqs])
     else: # TODO: ???
         clauses = And()
     clauses = formula_to_clauses(clauses)
     return ([n], clauses, false_clauses())
Esempio n. 8
0
 def action_update(self,domain,pvars):
     lhs = type_ast(domain,self.args[0])
     n = lhs.rep
     new_n = new(n)
     args = lhs.args
     vs = [Variable("X%d" % i,s) for i,s in enumerate(n.sort.dom)]
     eqs = [eq_atom(v,a) for (v,a) in zip(vs,args) if not isinstance(a,Variable)]
     if is_atom(lhs):
         clauses = And(*([Or(Not(Atom(new_n,vs)),Atom(n,vs),eq) for eq in eqs] +
                         [Or(Atom(new_n,vs),Not(Atom(n,vs)),eq) for eq in eqs]))
     elif is_individual_ast(lhs.rep):
         clauses = And(*[Or(eq_atom(type(lhs)(new_n,vs),type(lhs)(n,vs)),eq) for eq in eqs])
     else: # TODO: ???
         clauses = And()
     clauses = formula_to_clauses(clauses)
     return ([n], clauses, false_clauses())
Esempio n. 9
0
    def new_prop(expr):
        res = prop_abs.get(expr,None)
        if res is None:
            prev = prev_expr(stvarset,expr,sort_constants)
            if prev is not None:
#                print 'stvar: old: {} new: {}'.format(prev,expr)
                pva = new_prop(prev)
                res = tr.new(pva)
                new_stvars.append(pva)
                prop_abs[expr] = res  # prevent adding this again to new_stvars
            else:
                global prop_abs_ctr
                res = il.Symbol('__abs[{}]'.format(prop_abs_ctr),expr.sort)
#                print '{} = {}'.format(res,expr)
                prop_abs[expr] = res
                prop_abs_ctr += 1
        return res
Esempio n. 10
0
    def action_update(self, domain, pvars):
        lhs, rhs = self.args
        n = lhs.rep

        # Handle the hierarchical case
        if n in domain.hierarchy:
            asgns = [postfix_atoms_ast(self, Atom(x, [])) for x in domain.hierarchy[n]]
            res = unzip_append([asgn.action_update(domain, pvars) for asgn in asgns])
            return res

        # If the lhs application is partial, make it total by adding parameters
        xtra = len(lhs.rep.sort.dom) - len(lhs.args)
        if xtra < 0:
            raise IvyError(self, "too many parameters in assignment to " + lhs.rep)
        if xtra > 0:
            extend = sym_placeholders(lhs.rep)[-xtra:]
            extend = variables_distinct_list_ast(extend, self)  # get unused variables
            lhs = add_parameters_ast(lhs, extend)
            # Assignment of individual to a boolean is a special case
            if is_individual_ast(rhs) and not is_individual_ast(lhs):
                rhs = eq_atom(extend[-1], add_parameters_ast(rhs, extend[0:-1]))
            else:
                rhs = add_parameters_ast(rhs, extend)

        type_check(domain, rhs)
        if is_individual_ast(lhs) != is_individual_ast(rhs):
            #            print type(lhs.rep)
            #            print str(lhs.rep)
            #            print type(lhs.rep.sort)
            #            print "lhs: %s: %s" % (lhs,type(lhs))
            #            print "rhs: %s: %s" % (rhs,type(rhs))
            raise IvyError(self, "sort mismatch in assignment to {}".format(lhs.rep))

        new_n = new(n)
        args = lhs.args
        dlhs = new_n(*sym_placeholders(n))
        vs = dlhs.args
        eqs = [eq_atom(v, a) for (v, a) in zip(vs, args) if not isinstance(a, Variable)]
        rn = dict((a.rep, v) for v, a in zip(vs, args) if isinstance(a, Variable))
        drhs = substitute_ast(rhs, rn)
        if eqs:
            drhs = Ite(And(*eqs), drhs, n(*dlhs.args))
        new_clauses = Clauses([], [Definition(dlhs, drhs)])
        #        print "assign new_clauses = {}".format(new_clauses)
        return ([n], new_clauses, false_clauses())
Esempio n. 11
0
def to_aiger(mod,ext_act):

    erf = il.Symbol('err_flag',il.find_sort('bool'))
    errconds = []
    add_err_flag_mod(mod,erf,errconds)

    # we use a special state variable __init to indicate the initial state

    ext_acts = [mod.actions[x] for x in sorted(mod.public_actions)]
    ext_act = ia.EnvAction(*ext_acts)

    init_var = il.Symbol('__init',il.find_sort('bool')) 
    init = add_err_flag(ia.Sequence(*([a for n,a in mod.initializers]+[ia.AssignAction(init_var,il.And())])),erf,errconds)
    action = ia.Sequence(ia.AssignAction(erf,il.Or()),ia.IfAction(init_var,ext_act,init))
    
    # get the invariant to be proved, replacing free variables with
    # skolems. First, we apply any proof tactics.

    pc = ivy_proof.ProofChecker(mod.axioms,mod.definitions,mod.schemata)
    pmap = dict((lf.id,p) for lf,p in mod.proofs)
    conjs = []
    for lf in mod.labeled_conjs:
        if lf.id in pmap:
            proof = pmap[lf.id]
            subgoals = pc.admit_proposition(lf,proof)
            conjs.extend(subgoals)
        else:
            conjs.append(lf)

    invariant = il.And(*[il.drop_universals(lf.formula) for lf in conjs])
#    iu.dbg('invariant')
    skolemizer = lambda v: ilu.var_to_skolem('__',il.Variable(v.rep,v.sort))
    vs = ilu.used_variables_in_order_ast(invariant)
    sksubs = dict((v.rep,skolemizer(v)) for v in vs)
    invariant = ilu.substitute_ast(invariant,sksubs)
    invar_syms = ilu.used_symbols_ast(invariant)
    
    # compute the transition relation

    stvars,trans,error = action.update(mod,None)
    

#    print 'action : {}'.format(action)
#    print 'annotation: {}'.format(trans.annot)
    annot = trans.annot
#    match_annotation(action,annot,MatchHandler())
    
    indhyps = [il.close_formula(il.Implies(init_var,lf.formula)) for lf in mod.labeled_conjs]
#    trans = ilu.and_clauses(trans,indhyps)

    # save the original symbols for trace
    orig_syms = ilu.used_symbols_clauses(trans)
    orig_syms.update(ilu.used_symbols_ast(invariant))
                     
    # TODO: get the axioms (or maybe only the ground ones?)

    # axioms = mod.background_theory()

    # rn = dict((sym,tr.new(sym)) for sym in stvars)
    # next_axioms = ilu.rename_clauses(axioms,rn)
    # return ilu.and_clauses(axioms,next_axioms)

    funs = set()
    for df in trans.defs:
        funs.update(ilu.used_symbols_ast(df.args[1]))
    for fmla in trans.fmlas:
        funs.update(ilu.used_symbols_ast(fmla))
#   funs = ilu.used_symbols_clauses(trans)
    funs.update(ilu.used_symbols_ast(invariant))
    funs = set(sym for sym in funs if  il.is_function_sort(sym.sort))
    iu.dbg('[str(fun) for fun in funs]')

    # Propositionally abstract

    # step 1: get rid of definitions of non-finite symbols by turning
    # them into constraints

    new_defs = []
    new_fmlas = []
    for df in trans.defs:
        if len(df.args[0].args) == 0 and is_finite_sort(df.args[0].sort):
            new_defs.append(df)
        else:
            fmla = df.to_constraint()
            new_fmlas.append(fmla)
    trans = ilu.Clauses(new_fmlas+trans.fmlas,new_defs)

    # step 2: get rid of ite's over non-finite sorts, by introducing constraints

    cnsts = []
    new_defs = [elim_ite(df,cnsts) for df in trans.defs]
    new_fmlas = [elim_ite(fmla,cnsts) for fmla in trans.fmlas]
    trans = ilu.Clauses(new_fmlas+cnsts,new_defs)
    
    # step 3: eliminate quantfiers using finite instantiations

    from_asserts = il.And(*[il.Equals(x,x) for x in ilu.used_symbols_ast(il.And(*errconds)) if
                            tr.is_skolem(x) and not il.is_function_sort(x.sort)])
    iu.dbg('from_asserts')
    invar_syms.update(ilu.used_symbols_ast(from_asserts))
    sort_constants = mine_constants(mod,trans,il.And(invariant,from_asserts))
    sort_constants2 = mine_constants2(mod,trans,invariant)
    print '\ninstantiations:'
    trans,invariant = Qelim(sort_constants,sort_constants2)(trans,invariant,indhyps)
    
    
#    print 'after qe:'
#    print 'trans: {}'.format(trans)
#    print 'invariant: {}'.format(invariant)

    # step 4: instantiate the axioms using patterns

    # We have to condition both the transition relation and the
    # invariant on the axioms, so we define a boolean symbol '__axioms'
    # to represent the axioms.

    axs = instantiate_axioms(mod,stvars,trans,invariant,sort_constants,funs)
    ax_conj = il.And(*axs)
    ax_var = il.Symbol('__axioms',ax_conj.sort)
    ax_def = il.Definition(ax_var,ax_conj)
    invariant = il.Implies(ax_var,invariant)
    trans = ilu.Clauses(trans.fmlas+[ax_var],trans.defs+[ax_def])
    
    # step 5: eliminate all non-propositional atoms by replacing with fresh booleans
    # An atom with next-state symbols is converted to a next-state symbol if possible

    stvarset = set(stvars)
    prop_abs = dict()  # map from atoms to proposition variables
    global prop_abs_ctr  # sigh -- python lameness
    prop_abs_ctr = 0   # counter for fresh symbols
    new_stvars = []    # list of fresh symbols

    # get the propositional abstraction of an atom
    def new_prop(expr):
        res = prop_abs.get(expr,None)
        if res is None:
            prev = prev_expr(stvarset,expr,sort_constants)
            if prev is not None:
#                print 'stvar: old: {} new: {}'.format(prev,expr)
                pva = new_prop(prev)
                res = tr.new(pva)
                new_stvars.append(pva)
                prop_abs[expr] = res  # prevent adding this again to new_stvars
            else:
                global prop_abs_ctr
                res = il.Symbol('__abs[{}]'.format(prop_abs_ctr),expr.sort)
#                print '{} = {}'.format(res,expr)
                prop_abs[expr] = res
                prop_abs_ctr += 1
        return res

    # propositionally abstract an expression
    global mk_prop_fmlas
    mk_prop_fmlas = []
    def mk_prop_abs(expr):
        if il.is_quantifier(expr) or len(expr.args) > 0 and any(not is_finite_sort(a.sort) for a in expr.args):
            return new_prop(expr)
        return expr.clone(map(mk_prop_abs,expr.args))

    
    # apply propositional abstraction to the transition relation
    new_defs = map(mk_prop_abs,trans.defs)
    new_fmlas = [mk_prop_abs(il.close_formula(fmla)) for fmla in trans.fmlas]

    # find any immutable abstract variables, and give them a next definition

    def my_is_skolem(x):
        res = tr.is_skolem(x) and x not in invar_syms
        return res    
    def is_immutable_expr(expr):
        res = not any(my_is_skolem(sym) or tr.is_new(sym) or sym in stvarset for sym in ilu.used_symbols_ast(expr))
        return res
    for expr,v in prop_abs.iteritems():
        if is_immutable_expr(expr):
            new_stvars.append(v)
            print 'new state: {}'.format(expr)
            new_defs.append(il.Definition(tr.new(v),v))

    trans = ilu.Clauses(new_fmlas+mk_prop_fmlas,new_defs)

    # apply propositional abstraction to the invariant
    invariant = mk_prop_abs(invariant)

    # create next-state symbols for atoms in the invariant (is this needed?)
    rn = dict((sym,tr.new(sym)) for sym in stvars)
    mk_prop_abs(ilu.rename_ast(invariant,rn))  # this is to pick up state variables from invariant

    # update the state variables by removing the non-finite ones and adding the fresh state booleans
    stvars = [sym for sym in stvars if is_finite_sort(sym.sort)] + new_stvars

#    iu.dbg('trans')
#    iu.dbg('stvars')
#    iu.dbg('invariant')
#    exit(0)

    # For each state var, create a variable that corresponds to the input of its latch
    # Also, havoc all the state bits except the init flag at the initial time. This
    # is needed because in aiger, all latches start at 0!

    def fix(v):
        return v.prefix('nondet')
    def curval(v):
        return v.prefix('curval')
    def initchoice(v):
        return v.prefix('initchoice')
    stvars_fix_map = dict((tr.new(v),fix(v)) for v in stvars)
    stvars_fix_map.update((v,curval(v)) for v in stvars if v != init_var)
    trans = ilu.rename_clauses(trans,stvars_fix_map)
#    iu.dbg('trans')
    new_defs = trans.defs + [il.Definition(ilu.sym_inst(tr.new(v)),ilu.sym_inst(fix(v))) for v in stvars]
    new_defs.extend(il.Definition(curval(v),il.Ite(init_var,v,initchoice(v))) for v in stvars if  v != init_var)
    trans = ilu.Clauses(trans.fmlas,new_defs)
    
    # Turn the transition constraint into a definition
    
    cnst_var = il.Symbol('__cnst',il.find_sort('bool'))
    new_defs = list(trans.defs)
    new_defs.append(il.Definition(tr.new(cnst_var),fix(cnst_var)))
    new_defs.append(il.Definition(fix(cnst_var),il.Or(cnst_var,il.Not(il.And(*trans.fmlas)))))
    stvars.append(cnst_var)
    trans = ilu.Clauses([],new_defs)
    
    # Input are all the non-defined symbols. Output indicates invariant is false.

#    iu.dbg('trans')
    def_set = set(df.defines() for df in trans.defs)
    def_set.update(stvars)
#    iu.dbg('def_set')
    used = ilu.used_symbols_clauses(trans)
    used.update(ilu.symbols_ast(invariant))
    inputs = [sym for sym in used if
              sym not in def_set and not il.is_interpreted_symbol(sym)]
    fail = il.Symbol('__fail',il.find_sort('bool'))
    outputs = [fail]
    

#    iu.dbg('trans')
    
    # make an aiger

    aiger = Encoder(inputs,stvars,outputs)
    comb_defs = [df for df in trans.defs if not tr.is_new(df.defines())]

    invar_fail = il.Symbol('invar__fail',il.find_sort('bool'))  # make a name for invariant fail cond
    comb_defs.append(il.Definition(invar_fail,il.Not(invariant)))

    aiger.deflist(comb_defs)
    for df in trans.defs:
        if tr.is_new(df.defines()):
            aiger.set(tr.new_of(df.defines()),aiger.eval(df.args[1]))
    miter = il.And(init_var,il.Not(cnst_var),il.Or(invar_fail,il.And(fix(erf),il.Not(fix(cnst_var)))))
    aiger.set(fail,aiger.eval(miter))

#    aiger.sub.debug()

    # make a decoder for the abstract propositions

    decoder = dict((y,x) for x,y in prop_abs.iteritems())
    for sym in aiger.inputs + aiger.latches:
        if sym not in decoder and sym in orig_syms:
            decoder[sym] = sym

    cnsts = set(sym for syms in sort_constants.values() for sym in syms)
    return aiger,decoder,annot,cnsts,action,stvarset
Esempio n. 12
0
def forward_clauses(clauses, inflex):
    return lu.rename_clauses(
        clauses,
        dict((x, tr.new(x)) for x in lu.used_symbols_clauses(clauses)
             if x != '=' and x not in inflex))
Esempio n. 13
0
    print "inflex = {}".format(inflex)

    # get all the skolem symbols
    all_syms = sig.symbols
    skolems = set(sym for sym in all_syms if tr.is_skolem(sym))
    print "skolems = {}".format(skolems)

    # make frames explicit
    updates = [tr.frame_update(u, flex, sig) for u in updates]
    for u in updates:
        print u

    # locals are flexible and skolem symbols (next values unused for skolems)
    ns = sv.native_symbol
    #lsyms = [(ns(sym),ns(tr.new(sym))) for sym in chain(flex,skolems)]
    lsyms = [(ns(sym), ns(tr.new(sym))) for sym in chain(flex)]

    # globals are the inflexible symbols
    gsyms = [ns(sym) for sym in inflex]

    print "lsyms = {}".format(lsyms)
    print "gsyms = {}".format(gsyms)

    init = state.clauses
    init = forward_clauses(init, inflex)
    print "init = {}".format(init)

    error = forward_clauses(error, inflex)
    print "error = {}".format(error)

    axioms += forward_clauses(axioms, inflex)
Esempio n. 14
0
def forward_clauses(clauses,inflex):
    return lu.rename_clauses(clauses, dict((x,tr.new(x)) for x in lu.used_symbols_clauses(clauses)
        if x != '=' and x not in inflex))
Esempio n. 15
0
    print "inflex = {}".format(inflex)

    # get all the skolem symbols
    all_syms = sig.symbols
    skolems = set(sym for sym in all_syms if tr.is_skolem(sym))
    print "skolems = {}".format(skolems)

    # make frames explicit
    updates = [tr.frame_update(u,flex,sig) for u in updates]
    for u in updates:
        print u

    # locals are flexible and skolem symbols (next values unused for skolems)
    ns = sv.native_symbol
    #lsyms = [(ns(sym),ns(tr.new(sym))) for sym in chain(flex,skolems)]
    lsyms = [(ns(sym),ns(tr.new(sym))) for sym in chain(flex)]

    # globals are the inflexible symbols
    gsyms = [ns(sym) for sym in inflex]
    
    print "lsyms = {}".format(lsyms)
    print "gsyms = {}".format(gsyms)

    init = state.clauses
    init = forward_clauses(init,inflex)
    print "init = {}".format(init)

    error = forward_clauses(error,inflex)
    print "error = {}".format(error)

    axioms += forward_clauses(axioms,inflex)