def bigram_acc(transitions):
"""
Compute the bigram overlap (accuracy) for a list of predicted
Transitions.
transitions -- A list of discourse.hypergaph.Transition objects.
returns bigram overlap (accuracy)
"""
ntrans = len(transitions)
# Get predicted bigrams.
pred_bg = set([(s2i(t.sentences[1]), s2i(t.sentences[0], end='end'))
for t in recover_order(transitions)])
# Create gold bigrams.
gold = set([(i, i+1) for i in range(-1, ntrans - 2)])
gold.add((ntrans - 2, 'end'))
# If either sets are empty return None.
if len(pred_bg) == 0 or len(gold) == 0:
return None
nbigrams = len(gold)
acc = len(pred_bg & gold) / float(nbigrams)
return acc
def oso_acc(transitions):
ntrans = len(transitions)
# Get predicted bigrams.
pred = [s2i(t.sentences[0], end=ntrans-1)
for t in recover_order(transitions)]
if tuple(pred) == tuple([i for i in range(ntrans)]):
return 1
else:
return 0
def kendalls_tau(transitions):
"""
Compute Kendall's tau and pvalue for a list of
discourse.hypergraph.Transition objects.
transitions -- A list of discourse.hypergaph.Transition objects.
returns (kt, pval)
"""
# Get list sentence indices implied by the transition set.
indices = [s2i(t.sentences[0]) for t in recover_order(transitions)[:-1]]
# Get gold indices.
gold = [i for i in range(len(indices))]
# Compute Kendall's tau for these two sequences.
kt, pval = sp.stats.kendalltau(indices, gold)
return kt, pval
print_model_metrics(cutoff_trainY, cutoff_testY)
for i, datum in enumerate(izip(testX, gtestY[0:20], ptestY), 1):
print u'TEST NO: {:3}\n============\n'.format(i)
testx, gtesty, ptesty = datum
kt, pval = evaluation.kendalls_tau(ptesty)
print u'Kendall\'s Tau : {:.3f} (pval {:.3f})'.format(kt, pval)
print u'Bigram Acc. : {:.3f}'.format(evaluation.bigram_acc(ptesty))
print
print u'GOLD ORDERING\n==================\n'
print unicode(testx.trans2str(gtesty))
print
for t in hypergraph.recover_order(gtesty):
print u'TRANSITION: {}'.format(unicode(t))
print u'=' * 79
idx1 = hypergraph.s2i(t.sents[1])
sent1 = testx[idx1] if idx1 > -1 else 'START'
idx2 = hypergraph.s2i(t.sents[0])
sent2 = testx[idx2] if idx2 is not None else 'END'
print textwrap.fill(u'({:3}) {}'.format(idx1, unicode(sent1)))
print u' |\n V'
print textwrap.fill(u'({:3}) {}\n'.format(idx2, unicode(sent2)))
evaluation.explain_transition(t, model, testx)
print
def eval_against_baseline(testX, baselineY, newY, baseline_model, new_model,
base_feats, new_feats,
baseline_pred_trainY=None,
new_pred_trainY=None):
"""
Evaluate differences in two models. Prints out per instance
analysis of transitions predicted by baseline and new models.
testX -- A list of corenlp.Document objects to evaluate on.
baselineY -- A list of lists of discourse.hypergraph.Transition
objects predicted by the baseline model for the documents
in testX.
newY -- A list of lists of discourse.hypergraph.Transition
objects predicted by the new model for the documents
in testX.
baseline_model -- A discourse.perceptron.Perceptron object trained
on the features in base_feats.
new_model -- A discourse.perceptron.Perceptron object trained
on the features in new_feats.
base_feats -- A dict of feature names to boolean values,
indicating the features active in the baseline model.
new_feats -- A dict of feature names to boolean values,
indicating the features active in the new model.
"""
# Limit text output to 80 chars and wrap nicely.
wrapper = textwrap.TextWrapper(subsequent_indent='\t')
print u'OVERALL STATS FOR TEST DOCUMENTS'
# Print macro averaged Kendall's Tau and pvalues for baseline
# and new model.
bl_avg_kt, bl_avg_pval = avg_kendalls_tau(baselineY)
new_avg_kt, new_avg_pval = avg_kendalls_tau(newY)
print u'\t | BASELINE | NEW'
print u'{:14} {:.3f} ({:.3f}) | {:.3f} ({:.3f})\n'.format(u'Kendalls Tau',
bl_avg_kt,
bl_avg_pval,
new_avg_kt,
new_avg_pval)
# Print bigram gold sequence overlap (accuracy) for baseline and
# new model.
bl_bg_acc = mac_avg_bigram_acc(baselineY)
new_bg_acc = mac_avg_bigram_acc(newY)
print u'\t | BASELINE | NEW'
print u'{:12} | {:.3f} | {:.3f} \n'.format(u'bigram acc',
bl_bg_acc,
new_bg_acc)
if baseline_pred_trainY is not None or new_pred_trainY is not None:
if baseline_pred_trainY is not None:
bl_avg_kt_train, bl_avg_pval_train = avg_kendalls_tau(
baseline_pred_trainY)
bl_bg_acc_train = mac_avg_bigram_acc(baseline_pred_trainY)
else:
bl_avg_kt_train = float('nan')
bl_avg_pval_train = float('nan')
bl_bg_acc_train = float('nan')
if new_pred_trainY is not None:
new_avg_kt_train, new_avg_pval_train = avg_kendalls_tau(
new_pred_trainY)
new_bg_acc_train = mac_avg_bigram_acc(new_pred_trainY)
else:
new_avg_kt_train = float('nan')
new_avg_pval_train = float('nan')
new_bg_acc_train = float('nan')
print u'OVERALL STATS FOR TRAINING DOCUMENTS'
print u'\t | BASELINE | NEW'
print u'{:14} {:.3f} ({:.3f}) | {:.3f} ({:.3f})\n'.format(
u'Kendalls Tau',
bl_avg_kt_train,
bl_avg_pval_train,
new_avg_kt_train,
new_avg_pval_train)
print u'\t | BASELINE | NEW'
print u'{:12} | {:.3f} | {:.3f} \n'.format(u'bigram acc',
bl_bg_acc_train,
new_bg_acc_train)
# Print stats for individual test instances.
for test_idx, datum in enumerate(izip(testX, baselineY, newY), 1):
testx, baseliney, newy = datum
print u'TEST NO. {:4}\n=============\n'.format(test_idx)
# Print Kendalls Tau and pvalue for baseline and new model
# for this test instance.
bl_kt, bl_pval = kendalls_tau(baseliney)
new_kt, new_pval = kendalls_tau(newy)
print u'\t | BASELINE | NEW'
print u'{:14} {:.3f} ({:.3f}) | {:.3f} ({:.3f})\n'.format(u'K. Tau',
bl_kt,
bl_pval,
new_kt,
new_pval)
# Print bigram gold sequence overlap (accuracy) for baseline
# and new model.
bl_acc = bigram_acc(baseliney)
new_acc = bigram_acc(newy)
print u'\t | BASELINE | NEW'
print u'{:12} | {:.3f} | {:.3f} \n'.format(u'bigram acc',
bl_acc,
new_acc)
# Print document sentences in correct order.
print u'GOLD TEXT\n=========\n'
for i, s in enumerate(testx):
print wrapper.fill(u'({:3}) {}'.format(i, unicode(s)))
print u'\n\n'
# Print document sentences in baseline order.
print u'BASELINE TEXT\n=========\n'
indices = [s2i(t.sents[0]) for t in recover_order(baseliney)[:-1]]
for i in indices:
print wrapper.fill(u'({}) {}'.format(i, unicode(testx[i])))
print u'\n\n'
# Print document sentences in new model order.
print u'NEW MODEL TEXT\n=========\n'
indices = [s2i(t.sents[0]) for t in recover_order(newy)[:-1]]
for i in indices:
print wrapper.fill(u'({}) {}'.format(i, unicode(testx[i])))
print u'\n\n'
# Get predicted transitions in order for both models.
# NOTE: The predict function of the Perceptron object returns
# the predicted transitions in no particular order.
# When in doubt, use recover_order on any predicted output
# if you want to iterate over it as if you were traversing the
# graph of sentence transitions.
baseline_trans = discourse.hypergraph.recover_order(baseliney)
new_trans = discourse.hypergraph.recover_order(newy)
# Map tail sentence of a transition to the transition.
p2t_baseline = _position2transition_map(baseline_trans)
p2t_new = _position2transition_map(new_trans)
# For each transition leaving the same sentence, if the models
# disagree on what the next sentence is, print analysis of
# the model features.
for pos, t_bl in p2t_baseline.items():
if p2t_new[pos].sents[0] != t_bl.sents[0]:
t_new = p2t_new[pos]
# Print tail sentence.
if pos > -1:
pos_str = unicode(testx[pos])
else:
pos_str = u'START'
print u'=' * 80
print wrapper.fill(u'({:3}) {}'.format(pos, pos_str))
print (u'-' * 80)
print u' |\n V'
# Print baseline head sentence
if s2i(t_bl.sents[0]) is not None:
bl_str = unicode(testx[s2i(t_bl.sents[0])])
else:
bl_str = u'END'
print wrapper.fill(u'(OLD) {}\n'.format(bl_str)) + u'\n'
# Print baseline model features for the predicted
# baseline transition.
explain(t_bl, baseline_model, new_model, testx,
base_feats, new_feats)
# Print new model head sentence.
if s2i(t_new.sents[0]) is not None:
new_str = unicode(testx[s2i(t_new.sents[0])])
else:
new_str = 'END'
print wrapper.fill(u'(NEW) {}\n'.format(new_str)) + u'\n'
# Print new model features for the predicted new
# model transition.
explain(t_new, baseline_model, new_model, testx,
base_feats, new_feats)
# Print gold head sentence, that is, the sentence the
# models should have selected.
if pos + 1 < len(testx):
gstr = u'(GLD) {}\n'.format(unicode(testx[pos + 1]))
print wrapper.fill(gstr) + u'\n'
if pos + 1 == s2i(t_bl.sents[0], end=len(testx)):
print 'OLD MODEL IS CORRECT\n'
if pos + 1 == s2i(t_new.sents[0], end=len(testx)):
print 'NEW MODEL IS CORRECT\n'
print
